Archives

Try my other blogs:

Ants and Pine Tree Resin

On a recent camping trip near Payson, Arizona, I found ants in a pine tree. They seemed to be defending a crack in the tree filled with resin.

resin1

resin2

The area looked like this:

resin1a

I was interested in what they were doing, because I have read/seen conflicting information about the effects of pine resins on ants.

For example, in Tom Eisner’s For Love of Insects, he gives anecdotal evidence that ants are repelled by pine resin. Scientists have reported that stingless bees cover their nests with plant resins in response to ant attacks, suggesting the resins repel ants. One of the components of certain plant resins, limonene, is touted as a natural insecticide effective against ants (limonene is also found in citrus fruit peels).

The ants I had observed didn’t seem to be repelled by the resin. They were walking all over it, and apparently had a nest nearby.

I had also seen the video, Ants:  Nature’s Secret Power. In this section, wood ants are shown carrying resin back to their nest, at some cost to themselves. Take a look:

Experiments have shown that wood ants, Formica paralugubris, use pine resins as antibiotics, that is, as protection against pathogens.

Is this a case of one ant’s poison being another ant’s medicine? It seems likely that different species of ants would have different reactions to resins. Also, resins are not all identical. Some contain different terpenes, or higher levels of resin acids, which could change the level of repellency or antibiotic properties.

Seems like a relationship that needs further investigation. What do you think about ants and resins?

For further information:

Michel Chapuisat, Anne Oppliger, Pasqualina Magliano, and Philippe Christe. (2007). Wood ants use resin to protect themselves against pathogens. Proc. R. Soc. B. 274:  2013–2017.
Published online 29 May 2007
Paper is available online  for free

Lisette Lenoir, Jan Bengtsson, and Tryggve Persson. (2003). Effects of conifer resin on soil fauna in potential wood-ant nest materials at different moisture levels. Pedobiologia. 47 (1):  19-25.

Sara Diana Leonhardt and Nico Blüthgen. (2009). A Sticky Affair: Resin Collection by Bornean Stingless Bees. Biotropica. 41 (6): 730 - 736.

6 comments to Ants and Pine Tree Resin

  • [...] uncovers a conundrum about ants and their reaction to pine resin. Some love it and some hate it! Read on to find out if one ant’s poison is another [...]

  • What a great eye to notice this going on in the tree. You’re absolutely right: these don’t seem to be bothered by the resin at all.

  • Bill

    There are Harvester ants all over the Pine tree in my yard (Colorado) They look similar to the ants in your picture.

    There are Aphids infesting the tree and causing the sap and resin to leak. The Harvester ants are vigorously defending the Aphids, and in reward, they eat the secretions from the aphids. I’m trying to decide if I should step in with some pesticide and ruin their little symbiotic relationship.

  • Roberta

    Okay, I am really behind on this blog. Sorry for the delay.

    I suspect what is flowing from your tree would be honeydew if it from the aphids, rather than resin, which is produced by the tree itself. I recommend you take a few of the linsects to your local Cooperative Extension office for identification.

  • don

    i have what appears to be fire ants in all of my pine trees in my yard so they are attracted to something in these trees. i live in NC and they are especially bad this year but they are digging canals in my yard to and from these trees. its been a long battle.

  • Roberta

    Knowing for sure what kinds of ants you have can help you figure out what to do about them. You might want to send some ants to the School of Ants project to get them identified http://schoolofants.org/participate

Leave a Reply

 

 

 

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>